Share from 0:00
0:00
/

HR Harassment: Who Watches the Watchers? | Grounds for Discussion

The person paid to enforce the workplace rules staged a rose ceremony straight out of The Bachelor for a subordinate he was harassing. When the watchdog is the one behaving badly, who do you call?

Roast the Post: Grounds for Discussion

Grounds for Discussion delivers a short, unfiltered analysis on the headlines shaping organizations and the world of work. In each episode, Jen and Paul dissect one key story with sharp, bullsh*t-free insights. No fluff, just the deep dives that workplace professionals need to stay ahead of the curve.

Share


Sources

Writer, Staff. “HR Manager’s Staged Award Ceremony Led to Sex Harassment Firing at Federal Department | HR Law Canada.” HR Law Canada, HR Law Canada, 15 Sept. 2026, hrlawcanada.com/2026/09/hr-managers-staged-award-ceremony-led-to-sex-harassment-firing-at-federal-department/.

MBFC bias and factuality rating for this source : Unrated

The Issues

Workplace harassment policy usually assumes a functioning escalation path: employee reports an issue to HR, HR investigates, leadership acts. That assumption collapses when the alleged harasser sits inside HR itself. A federal adjudicator recently upheld the firing of an HR team leader who spent nearly two years pursuing a subordinate, culminating in a staged award ceremony with flowers, sparkling wine, and recorded applause.

The case is extreme, but the structural problem it exposes is ordinary: HR holds power and authority over broad swaths of an organization, yet the channels that hold everyone else accountable often run through HR itself. Boards, executive leadership, and third-party whistleblower channels exist in theory, but in small organizations without formalized governance, they often don’t exist at all.

Whoever ends up as the final accountable authority carries the risk of being the one who behaves badly, and no amount of layered oversight fully eliminates that. The honest question isn’t whether the system can prevent every bad actor. It’s whether the people most responsible for enforcing workplace ethics have anywhere to turn when the bad actor is one of them.

Questions to Consider

Who investigates harassment complaints against HR professionals?

When the accused works in HR, the complaint needs to bypass HR entirely, typically going to senior leadership, a governance board, or an external third-party channel. Escalation paths that route through the same function the complaint targets aren’t independent and will fail the people who need them.

In practice, independence is the hard part. Some organizations contract third-party whistleblower or grievance services precisely so that complaints about HR, or about executives with HR allies, have somewhere to land. In the public sector, labour relations boards provide genuine external adjudication: in the case behind this episode, the Federal Public Sector Labour Relations and Employment Board reviewed the firing and refused reinstatement, finding the HR team leader repeatedly harassed subordinates and abused his authority.

The adjudicator noted it was difficult to understand how he had been promoted into the role despite an earlier warning. That detail is the real lesson for organizational design: oversight after the fact only works if someone is willing to act on the warning signs before promotion, and the function’s own closeness to the process is exactly what keeps that from happening.

Are HR professionals held to a higher standard of conduct than other employees?

Not formally, in most organizations. HR professionals are generally subject to the same conduct policies as everyone else, but they carry greater practical exposure because their role gives them authority over how those policies are applied to others, and their own misconduct corrodes trust in the entire system.

There’s a credible argument for different rather than higher standards. HR roles come with constraints other employees don’t face: professional distance is a core tool of the job, because friendship and intimacy with the people you may one day have to investigate or discipline compromises that authority. The trade-off rarely acknowledged is that HR is simultaneously held to stricter behavioural expectations and given weaker support when they’re the ones harmed. Every other employee has an escalation path if HR functions properly.

When something happens to HR, that path runs through their own team or the person they report to, and if that’s the CEO, there’s often nowhere to go. Higher expectations with no independent support system is an imbalance worth fixing regardless of how you feel about the profession.

What can employees do when the harasser works in HR?

Document everything, then escalate outside the accused’s chain of influence: a different HR leader, a senior executive, a board member, or an external body such as a labour board or human rights commission. If the organization has a third-party whistleblower line, use it, because it’s the only channel the accused can’t influence.

In Canada, workplace sexual harassment is prohibited under human rights legislation and, for federally regulated workplaces, under the Canada Labour Code, which requires employers to investigate and address complaints. Where internal processes are compromised, external routes remain: provincial and federal human rights commissions, and for public-sector employees, labour relations adjudication.

That’s effectively what happened here. The harassment in this case only came to a formal, binding conclusion through an external board decision, not through the department’s internal machinery. Employees should also know that harassment doesn’t require a pattern: a single severe incident can qualify, though repeated conduct, like the near-two-year pursuit documented in this case, makes the pattern unmistakable. The uncomfortable takeaway is that internal systems are designed for the average case. When the accused is inside the system, your fastest route to resolution is usually the one that leaves the building.


Support the Show

Roast the Post is a passion project of Jennifer Houle and Paul Austin-Menear. The show helps job-seekers and employers get dud job ads out of their lives. There are several ways that you can help us on our mission to unf*ck the hiring process…

1 —> Share this episode with someone who’d like it.

Share

2 —> Pick up a copy of our new e-Book, the Job Description Decoder and leave a review. The price is pay-what-you-can (even free), and all proceeds will be donated equally to Ronald McDonald House BC & Yukon, and the Toronto Humane Society.

GET THE BOOK

3 —> Send us a one-time or recurring tip on Buy Me a Coffee. This helps pay for our production costs.

SUPPORT THE SHOW

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?